---
title: "Ask EiE: Are Contests OK in the Engineering Classroom?"
description: Should you let classroom engineering be a competition? EiE recommends that teachers promote the 21st century skill of collaboration.
image: https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/Blog_Images/2015.10.22_EIE_2015_Windmills_8_small.jpg
---

[![Return to yes.mos.org](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/YES-Horizontal-4c.png "Return to yes.mos.org")](https://yes.mos.org)

![](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Logos/blog-pipe.png)

[![Go to the YES Blog homepage](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Logos/blog-title.png "Go to the YES Blog homepage")](https://yesblog.mos.org)

# Ask EiE: Are Contests OK in the Engineering Classroom?

Posted by [Cynthia Berger](https://yesblog.mos.org/author/cynthia-berger) on Thursday, October 22, 2015

![EiE "Catching the Wind, Lesson 3: Designing a sail for a boat.](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Blog_Images/2015.10.22_EIE_2015_Windmills_8_small.jpg?width=290&height=226&name=2015.10.22_EIE_2015_Windmills_8_small.jpg "EiE \"Catching the Wind, Lesson 3: Designing a sail for a boat.")*Each Thursday on the EiE Blog we offer tips for teachers of elementary engineering*.

To answer today's question, let's take a look at Lesson 3 of the Engineering is Elementary (EiE) unit *[Catching the Wind: Designing Windmills. ](http://www.eie.org/eie-curriculum/curriculum-units/catching-wind-designing-windmills)*This lesson engages students in designing sails with different shapes from a variety of materials. Once their sail is constructed, kids attach it to a little raft mounted on a track, turn on an electric fan to generate “wind,” and measure how far their raft sails down the track. Often, teachers like to set up more than one sail track, so that testing can proceed faster . . . but then students ask if they can race. Should you let a sailboat race be part of the activity?

***[See it in action: Watch this lesson](http://www.eie.org/eie-curriculum/resources/testing-sail-designs-2-grade-2-framingham-ma)****!*

Allowing for classroom competition is a traditional approach to learning, and in some situations it can be very effective. But when elementary school-aged kids engineer, it’s optimal to put the emphasis on [collaboration](http://blog.eie.org/working-in-teams-is-an-engineering-habit-of-mind). Let’s take a look at the evidence on both sides.

#### Competition Can Be Fun, But . . . 

On the one hand, competitions can be really fun—they generate excitement and drama. Competition is motivating for some students; winners feel great because their designs worked well. And some educators argue that competition in the classroom prepares kids for the future, that when students eventually graduate into the world of work, they’ll experience competitive situations, so they should be ready and resilient.

![EiE students get ready to test how well a sail catches the wind. ](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/Blog_Images/2015.10.22_EIE_2015_Windmills_12_small.jpg?width=290&height=234&name=2015.10.22_EIE_2015_Windmills_12_small.jpg "EiE students get ready to test how well a sail catches the wind. ")But when your classroom activities emphasize competition, the students who don’t win may feel frustrated, angry, and turned off. Life deals different hands; realistically, the deck is stacked to favor kids from certain demographics . . . and the kids themselves know it. Everyone brings different experiences, backgrounds, and skills to their school activities, and competitions can unintentionally emphasize or reinforce these differences.

On top of the issue of equity, for some students fear of failure can become paralyzing. If you’re not likely to win, why even try? Even the kids who often win can be adversely affected by competitions; they may become obsessed with worry over what will happen if they don’t win the next time.

Also, when your teams of student engineers compete against each other, it affects the group dynamics inside each team. Students may see their teammates less as actual teammates (as members of a learning community), and more as tools (or obstacles) to winning. Kids who are focused on winning—doing it faster, getting the best result—may feel that positive classroom practices like discussing and reflecting just aren’t worth the time, that they slow the trajectory of getting to a successful solution. Kids who share offbeat ideas that are outside the box may feel sanctioned, not supported.

Think about what you hope students will take away from engineering lessons. Competitions tend to put the emphasis on outcome over process: learning in order to get a reward, as opposed to learning for the satisfaction (and long-term benefit) of learning.

#### Keep It Real: Keep It Collaborative

We strongly recommend that when your young students are engineering, you keep things collaborative. First of all, that’s what engineers really do: work in teams, share information, and use group knowledge to come up with the best solutions.

Secondly, when you help young students develop the [21st century skills](http://eie.org/sites/default/files/eie_research_summary_8_2014_0.pdf) of cooperation, collaboration, and effective communication, these skills [will help them succeed](http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/24/building-social-skills-to-do-well-in-math/?_r=0) as they continue through school . . .  and on into the modern world of work. When you promote cooperation in the classroom, you help to build a future where this approach is respected and effective.

One other key benefit of promoting collaboration: There’s plenty of [research](https://www.nea.org/tools/16870.htm) to show that when students work together—when they collaborate and engage in peer teaching—they actually learn better. Different students have different strengths, and collaborating on a design challenge lets everyone bring those strengths to the table. It’s smooth sailing all around.

*Engineering is Elementary is a project of the [National Center for Technological Literacy®](http://www.eie.org/engineering-elementary/about-national-center-technological-literacy%C2%AE) at the [Museum of Science, Boston](http://www.eie.org/engineering-elementary/about-museum-science-boston)*.

 

 

 

 

 

- [Tweet](https://twitter.com/share)

#### Written by [Cynthia Berger](https://yesblog.mos.org/author/cynthia-berger)

 Topics: [Classroom Organization](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/classroom-organization), [EiE Teaching Tips](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-teaching-tips)

[Next Post](https://yesblog.mos.org/spotlight-on-k-12-stem-education-in-massachusetts) [Blog Home](https://yesblog.mos.org) [Previous Post](https://yesblog.mos.org/innovative-approach-to-eie-pd-puts-a-coach-in-the-classroom)

### Subscribe to Email Updates

**Recent Posts**

[Engineering Practices: Envisioning Multiple Solutions](https://yesblog.mos.org/engineering-practices-considering-multiple-solutions)

Mon, May 11

[Engineering Practices: Balancing Criteria and Constraints](https://yesblog.mos.org/engineering-practices-criteria-and-constraints)

Sat, Apr 18

[Simple Ways Teachers Can Involve Families in STEM Learning](https://yesblog.mos.org/help-families-engage-with-stem)

Thu, Mar 26

[Plan a Super STEM Summer Camp with YES Engineering Activities](https://yesblog.mos.org/summer-2026)

Thu, Mar 19

### Posts by Topic

- [Create a Generation of Problem Solvers (129)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/create-a-generation-of-problem-solvers)
- [EiE Resources for Teachers (114)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-resources-for-teachers)
- [EiE Teaching Tips (107)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-teaching-tips)
- [Engineering for All (85)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-for-all)
- [Early Childhood STEM Education (77)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/early-childhood-stem-education)
- [Implementing EiE (71)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/implementing-eie)
- [Professional Development (69)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/professional-development)
- [Out-of-School time (65)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/out-of-school-time)
- [STEM Implementation (54)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-implementation)
- [Computer Science (50)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/computer-science)
- [Virtual Learning (42)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/virtual-learning)
- [Engineering is Elementary (40)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-is-elementary)
- [Profiles (40)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/profiles)
- [Engineering Habits of Mind (37)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-habits-of-mind)
- [Afterschool/Summer Camp (29)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/afterschool-summer-camp)
- [Early Engineering (28)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/early-engineering)
- [Engineering Activities (25)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-activities)
- [Engineering Everywhere (25)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-everywhere)
- [Afterschool (23)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/afterschool)
- [EiE Research Results (21)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-research-results)
- [EiE for Families (21)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-for-families)
- [Engineering in Elementary STEM Education (19)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-in-elementary-stem-education)
- [Engineering Adventures (17)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-adventures)
- [Engineering Design Process (16)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-design-process)
- [Museum of Science (16)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/museum-of-science)
- [STEM Education (16)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-education)
- [Wee Engineer (15)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/wee-engineer)
- [MOS at School (14)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/mos-at-school)
- [Classroom Organization (13)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/classroom-organization)
- [Scholarships and Awards (13)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/scholarships-and-awards)
- [YES Curricula (13)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/yes-curricula)
- [Classroom (12)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/classroom)
- [Digital Storybooks (12)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/digital-storybooks)
- [EiE Ambassador (12)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-ambassador)
- [STEM Learning (12)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-learning)
- [Social Emotional Learning (12)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/social-emotional-learning)
- [EiE for Kindergarten (11)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-for-kindergarten)
- [Engineering and English Language Arts (11)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-and-english-language-arts)
- [Funding (11)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/funding)
- [STEM Funding (11)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-funding)
- [Careers for Engineers (10)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/careers-for-engineers)
- [Climate Change (10)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/climate-change)
- [EiE Families (10)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-families)
- [Learn.EiE (9)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/learn-eie)
- [Pre-K (9)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/pre-k)
- [Preschool (8)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/preschool)
- [Professional Learning (8)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/professional-learning)
- [Durable Skills (7)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/durable-skills)
- [Elementary School (7)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/elementary-school)
- [Kindergarten (7)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/kindergarten)
- [Black History Month (6)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/black-history-month)
- [Engineering Practices (6)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-practices)
- [Middle School (6)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/middle-school)
- [Online PD (6)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/online-pd)
- [Women's History Month (6)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/womens-history-month)
- [Assessment (5)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/assessment)
- [Christine Cunningham (5)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/christine-cunningham)
- [Engineering Education (5)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-education)
- [Webinar (5)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/webinar)
- [Curriculum (4)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/curriculum)
- [EiE Partnership (4)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/eie-partnership)
- [Pilot Testers/Pilot Testing (4)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/pilot-testers-pilot-testing)
- [STEM Activities (4)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-activities)
- [YES Enrichment (4)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/yes-enrichment)
- [Cross Curricular Connections (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/cross-curricular-connections)
- [Earth Day (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/earth-day)
- [Emergent Multilingual Learners (MLLs) (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/emergent-multilingual-learners-mlls)
- [English Language Learners (ELLs) (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/english-language-learners-ells)
- [Interviews & Appearances (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/interviews-appearances)
- [Mass STEM Week (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/mass-stem-week)
- [MathWorks (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/mathworks)
- [Media (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/media)
- [NASA (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/nasa)
- [Pride in STEM (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/pride-in-stem)
- [STEM Day (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-day)
- [STEM Teachers & Educators (3)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-teachers-educators)
- [AAPI (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/aapi)
- [AAPI Heritage Month (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/aapi-heritage-month)
- [Artificial Intelligence (AI) (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/artificial-intelligence-ai)
- [Essentials (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/essentials)
- [High school (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/high-school)
- [Indigenous Peoples' Day (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/indigenous-peoples-day)
- [Latin Heritage Month (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/latin-heritage-month)
- [Math Connections (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/math-connections)
- [NSF- National Science Foundation (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/nsf-national-science-foundation)
- [National Grid (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/national-grid)
- [Out of School (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/out-of-school)
- [Podcast (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/podcast)
- [Preservice Teachers (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/preservice-teachers)
- [STEM Careers/Careers in STEM (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-careers-careers-in-stem)
- [STEM Event (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-event)
- [Scientific American (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/scientific-american)
- [Spanish Resources (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/spanish-resources)
- [Teacher Appreciation Week (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/teacher-appreciation-week)
- [Teacher Educator Institute (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/teacher-educator-institute)
- [YES in the Media (2)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/yes-in-the-media)
- [Asteroid Day (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/asteroid-day)
- [Augmented Reality (AR) (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/augmented-reality-ar)
- [Behind the Scenes (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/behind-the-scenes)
- [Careers (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/careers)
- [ChangED (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/changed)
- [Childhood Learning (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/childhood-learning)
- [Climate (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/climate)
- [Computational Thinking (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/computational-thinking)
- [Conference (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/conference)
- [Congress/Congressional Briefing (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/congress-congressional-briefing)
- [DEAIB (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/deaib)
- [Day of AI (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/day-of-ai)
- [Dell Technologies (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/dell-technologies)
- [Dream Big (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/dream-big)
- [EarthShot (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/earthshot)
- [Earthshot/Year of Earthshot (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/earthshot-year-of-earthshot)
- [Engineering Careers & Jobs (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/engineering-careers-jobs)
- [English Learner (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/english-learner)
- [Environmental Education Week (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/environmental-education-week)
- [Explore Interactive, Inc./MindLabs (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/explore-interactive-inc-mindlabs)
- [Great Outdoors Month (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/great-outdoors-month)
- [Halloween (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/halloween)
- [Holiday STEM (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/holiday-stem)
- [Holiday STEM (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/holiday-stem)
- [International Science Museum Day (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/international-science-museum-day)
- [Lemelson Foundation (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/lemelson-foundation)
- [MA STEM Teacher Fair (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/ma-stem-teacher-fair)
- [MA STEM Week (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/ma-stem-week)
- [MCIU Learning Network (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/mciu-learning-network)
- [Mass EoE (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/mass-eoe)
- [Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/massachusetts-institute-of-technology-mit)
- [National Coding Week (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/national-coding-week)
- [National Engineers' Week (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/national-engineers-week)
- [National Robotics Week (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/national-robotics-week)
- [National Science Foundation/NSF (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/national-science-foundation-nsf)
- [National Space Day (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/national-space-day)
- [Native American Heritage Month (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/native-american-heritage-month)
- [Op-eds/Opinion Editorials (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/op-eds-opinion-editorials)
- [Outreach/Social Media (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/outreach-social-media)
- [Overdeck Family Foundation (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/overdeck-family-foundation)
- [PLANETS (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/planets)
- [Problem Solvers (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/problem-solvers)
- [Project Vaccine (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/project-vaccine)
- [Reading/Writing (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/reading-writing)
- [SLECop Convening (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/slecop-convening)
- [STEM Careers (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-careers)
- [STEM in the Future (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/stem-in-the-future)
- [Scratch Week (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/scratch-week)
- [Summer Learning (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/summer-learning)
- [Sustainability (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/sustainability)
- [TeacherCast (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/teachercast)
- [Technology (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/technology)
- [Technology/Education Technology (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/technology-education-technology)
- [Thanksgiving (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/thanksgiving)
- [Women in Engineering Day (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/women-in-engineering-day)
- [World Computer Literacy Day (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/world-computer-literacy-day)
- [World Space Week (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/world-space-week)
- [YES Careers (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/yes-careers)
- [YES Teacher Development (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/yes-teacher-development)
- [YES in School (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/yes-in-school)
- [YES/EiE at Home (1)](https://yesblog.mos.org/topic/yes-eie-at-home)

see all

| [![Facebook](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Social/sm.fb.icon.svg)](https://www.facebook.com/yesatmos/) | [![logo-black-1](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/logo-black-1.png?width=32&height=33&name=logo-black-1.png)](https://twitter.com/yesatmos) | [![Pinterest](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Social/sm.pin.icon.svg)](https://www.pinterest.com/yesatmos/) | [![YouTube](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Social/sm.yt.icon.svg)](https://www.youtube.com/@youthengineeringsolutions) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |

Search the EiE Blog

Search

| [![MOS](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Logos/EiE.MOS.EiE%20Full%20Lockup-939086-edited-997523-edited.png?width=64&name=EiE.MOS.EiE%20Full%20Lockup-939086-edited-997523-edited.png)](https://www.mos.org) | ![](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Logos/blog-pipe.png) | [![YES logo horizontal](https://yesblog.mos.org/hubfs/YES-Horizontal-4c.png)](https://eie.org) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| [![Facebook](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Social/sm.fb.icon.png?width=24&height=24&name=sm.fb.icon.png)](https://www.facebook.com/yesatmos/)  [![logo-black](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/logo-black.png?width=24&height=24&name=logo-black.png)](https://twitter.com/yesatmos)  [![Pinterest](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Social/sm.pin.icon.png?width=24&height=24&name=sm.pin.icon.png)](https://www.pinterest.com/yesatmos/)  [![YouTube](https://yesblog.mos.org/hs-fs/hubfs/2017%20Redesign%20Template%20Resources/Social/sm.yt.icon.png?width=24&height=24&name=sm.yt.icon.png)](https://www.youtube.com/@youthengineeringsolutions)  |  |  |

© 2026 YES | Museum of Science